Mattinson Wine Reviews.
Every wine on this page scored 89/100 or better. Every wine was tasted, scored and written up by Campbell Mattinson. Every day, wines are rejected for publication – if it doesn't make the cut, it doesn't appear.
Wineries: to submit your wine for review, click Submit Wines below.
Michael Hall Mount Torrens Syrah 2024
Michael Hall Mount Torrens Syrah 2024, from the Adelaide Hills, rated 94 points; “This wine is so fresh, so buoyant, and so pretty.”
Pokolbin Vintners Pokolbin Mountain Dry Red 2025
“It lilts and lifts its way through your mouth, rather than acting with brute force. It’s a pleasure to drink, as a result.” Mattinson on Pokolbin Vintners Pokolbin Mountain Dry Red 2025.
Pokolbin Vintners Pokolbin Mountain Dry Red 2024
“The purity of this wine is quite something. The flow. The way it carries you along.” Mattinson on the Pokolbin Vintners Pokolbin Mountain Dry Red 2024.
Pokolbin Vintners Pokolbin Mountain Dry Red 2023
“This is not a big wine, and nor does it need to be. But it is a truly beautiful wine, start to finish.” – Mattinson on the Pokolbin Vintners Pokolbin Mountain Dry Red 2023.
Penfolds Grange Shiraz 2022
The 75th-anniversary Grange is a cooler-vintage wine — more 1999 than 1998 — with length and tannin to burn, and a $1000 price that hasn't moved in five years. The full review, and the score.
Brokenwood Graveyard Shiraz 2024
"A celebration of beauty." Campbell Mattinson's 95+ point review of Brokenwood Graveyard Shiraz 2024 — a medium-bodied Hunter Valley icon built to cellar.
Brokenwood Graveyard Shiraz 2023
"There's a magic in our midst." Campbell Mattinson's 96-point review of Brokenwood Graveyard Shiraz 2023 — the Hunter Valley icon, now more understated.
Coppabella Procella I Hilltops Shiraz 2022
Mattinson review of Coppabella Procella I Hilltops Shiraz 2022.