Mattinson Wine Reviews.
Every wine on this page scored 89/100 or better. Every wine was tasted, scored and written up by Campbell Mattinson. Every day, wines are rejected for publication – if it doesn't make the cut, it doesn't appear.
Wineries: to submit your wine for review, click Submit Wines below.
Otway Wines Reserve Pinot Noir 2024
“You’d be hard-pressed to find a more savoury pinot noir.” Campbell Mattinson’s 92+ point review of Otway Wines Reserve Pinot Noir 2024 – a complex Geelong Pinot for the table.
Yering Station Reserve Pinot Noir 2017
“As complex as it is powerful… quite a pinot noir.” Campbell Mattinson’s 95-point review of the museum-release Yering Station Reserve Pinot Noir 2017, from the Yarra Valley.
Wilimee Granite Pinot Noir 2025
“Fabulous… wine isn’t about scores.” Campbell Mattinson’s 95-point review of Wilimee Granite Pinot Noir 2025 – a complex, finely balanced Macedon Ranges Pinot, just 50 dozen made.
Wilimee Cambrian Pinot Noir 2025
“The kind of pinot that sends you scurrying to your notebook.” Campbell Mattinson’s 95-point review of Wilimee Cambrian Pinot Noir 2025 – a superb Macedon Ranges Pinot.
Savaterre Pinot Noir 2024
“It’s wonderful. That’s what it is. Wonderful.” Campbell Mattinson’s 96-point review of Savaterre Pinot Noir 2024 – a complex, joyous Beechworth Pinot Noir.
Curly Flat Reserve Pinot Noir 2024
“A seductive pinot noir” that promises to be seriously good – Campbell Mattinson’s 93+ point review of Curly Flat Reserve Pinot Noir 2024, from the Macedon Ranges. Cellar it.
Lambrook ALOFT Pinot Noir 2026
“You can’t argue with the value.” Campbell Mattinson’s 91-point review of Lambrook ALOFT Pinot Noir 2026 – a fleshy, silky Adelaide Hills Pinot Noir at $25.
Lambrook Trueheart Pinot Noir 2026
A light, crisp, savoury Adelaide Hills Pinot Noir at $25 – Campbell Mattinson’s 89-point review of Lambrook Trueheart Pinot Noir 2026. Refreshing and food-friendly.
Austin’s Pinot Noir 2024
A complex, savoury Geelong Pinot Noir – Campbell Mattinson's 91-point review of Austin's Pinot Noir 2024. Complexity in spades, and as much about earth as fruit.
Vignerons Schmölzer & Brown Brunnen Pinot Noir 2024
A light, cool-tempered, savoury Beechworth Pinot – Campbell Mattinson's 93-point review of Schmölzer & Brown Brunnen Pinot Noir 2024. Fresh and delicate, complex and lovely.
Coppabella The Crest Pinot Noir 2021
Soft, silken and drinking at its peak – Campbell Mattinson's 91-point review of Coppabella The Crest Pinot Noir 2021, a juicy Tumbarumba Pinot Noir.
Moppity Vineyards Lock & Key Pinot Noir 2025
A well-structured, fragrant Tumbarumba Pinot at $35 – Campbell Mattinson's 91-point review of Moppity Vineyards Lock & Key Pinot Noir 2025. Drink now or cellar a few years.
Tolpuddle Pinot Noir 2025
"Stand and admire, and sink into." Campbell Mattinson's 95-point review of Tolpuddle Pinot Noir 2025 — structured, generous, and still rising fast. Tasmania.
Au Bon Climat Pinot Noir 2024
"If I lived in the US, this would be my house pinot." Campbell Mattinson's 93+ point review of Au Bon Climat Pinot Noir 2024, from California's Santa Maria Valley.
Russell & Suitor Ladera Pinot Noir 2025
Mattinson review of Russell & Suitor Ladera Pinot Noir 2025.
Chatto Killara Farm Pinot Noir 2025
"Serious Pinot Noir, screwed tight, presence intact." Campbell Mattinson's 94-point review of Chatto Killara Farm Pinot Noir 2025, from Tasmania.
Chatto Bird Pinot Noir 2025
"Champion of a wine." Campbell Mattinson's 95-point review of Chatto Bird Pinot Noir 2025, from Tasmania.
Chatto Seven Inch Pinot Noir 2025
The bottle of pinot noir you always hope to encounter: frisky and sure-footed, nervy and composed, fruit and mineral in balance. A ripping Tasmanian release. 95 points.
Garagiste Le Stagiaire Pinot Noir 2025
Campbell Mattinson calls Garagiste Le Stagiaire Pinot Noir 2025, from the Mornington Peninsula, "a definite buy".
