Mattinson Wine Reviews.
Every wine on this page scored 89/100 or better. Every wine was tasted, scored and written up by Campbell Mattinson. Every day, wines are rejected for publication – if it doesn't make the cut, it doesn't appear.
Wineries: to submit your wine for review, click Submit Wines below.
Curly Flat Pinot Noir 2024
“A rock-solid release” – Campbell Mattinson’s 94-point review of Curly Flat Pinot Noir 2024, a Macedon Ranges Pinot of perfume, power and structure. Cellars well, drinks well now.
Wilimee Granite Pinot Noir 2025
“Fabulous… wine isn’t about scores.” Campbell Mattinson’s 95-point review of Wilimee Granite Pinot Noir 2025 – a complex, finely balanced Macedon Ranges Pinot, just 50 dozen made.
Wilimee Cambrian Pinot Noir 2025
“The kind of pinot that sends you scurrying to your notebook.” Campbell Mattinson’s 95-point review of Wilimee Cambrian Pinot Noir 2025 – a superb Macedon Ranges Pinot.
Savaterre Pinot Noir 2024
“It’s wonderful. That’s what it is. Wonderful.” Campbell Mattinson’s 96-point review of Savaterre Pinot Noir 2024 – a complex, joyous Beechworth Pinot Noir.
Tolpuddle Pinot Noir 2025
"Stand and admire, and sink into." Campbell Mattinson's 95-point review of Tolpuddle Pinot Noir 2025 — structured, generous, and still rising fast. Tasmania.
Chatto Killara Farm Pinot Noir 2025
"Serious Pinot Noir, screwed tight, presence intact." Campbell Mattinson's 94-point review of Chatto Killara Farm Pinot Noir 2025, from Tasmania.
Chatto Bird Pinot Noir 2025
"Champion of a wine." Campbell Mattinson's 95-point review of Chatto Bird Pinot Noir 2025, from Tasmania.
Chatto Seven Inch Pinot Noir 2025
The bottle of pinot noir you always hope to encounter: frisky and sure-footed, nervy and composed, fruit and mineral in balance. A ripping Tasmanian release. 95 points.
Garagiste Le Stagiaire Pinot Noir 2025
Campbell Mattinson calls Garagiste Le Stagiaire Pinot Noir 2025, from the Mornington Peninsula, "a definite buy".
Scotsburn Lava Flow Pinot Noir 2025
Mattinson review of Scotsburn Lava Flow Pinot Noir 2025.
Scotsburn Ancient Sea Pinot Noir 2025
"Surly, sultry, seductive." Campbell Mattinson's 94-point review of Scotsburn Ancient Sea Pinot Noir 2025 — grown in ancient seabed soils near Ballarat.
Coppabella Pinot Noir 2025
"It’s impossible not to be impressed." Campbell Mattinson in his 94 Point review of Coppabella Pinot Noir 2025, from Tumbarumba.
Coppabella Procella IV Tumbarumba Pinot Noir 2025
Mattinson review of Coppabella Procella IV Tumbarumba Pinot Noir 2025.
Shadowfax Little Hampton Pinot Noir 2024
Mattinson review of Shadowfax Little Hampton Pinot Noir 2024.
Stonier Pinot Noir 2025
The best standard Stonier Pinot in 30 years, at $45 — Campbell Mattinson's 95-point review, and a Best Value Pinot of 2026 contender.